Editing Checklist
Below is a list of common items I edit. I provide different levels of editing depending on your needs. The most common preference is a light-medium copyedit, which includes mechanical editing and language
editing (listed below). I recommend this type of editing for most authors.
​
For authors needing more than a light-medium edit, you have the option of a more heavy copyedit that could also include content editing, correlating parts, editing references, and aligning manuscripts with a journal's author guidelines. See below for a description of what is included in each of these options.
​
Please let me know if you prefer a light-medium or heavy copyedit. And if you need a heavy copyedit, please specify what categories you need edited. Please see my Price & Payment page for details about cost. A heavy copyedit takes longer, so cost increases.
​
Also note, that I do proofread documents, but this is a very light edit that is typically applied to a manuscript that has been through multiple revisions and copyediting. Proofreading involves the most minimal changes, correcting any possible typos and punctuation errors that may remain in a text before being approved for publication.
​
MECHANICAL EDITING
This includes following guidelines of a style manual for these items:
​
-
Punctuation
-
Spelling
-
Capitalization
-
Hyphenation
-
Page numbers, headers and footers
-
Italicization, underscoring, and boldfaced type
-
Abbreviations, including acronyms and initialisms
-
Quotations
-
Tables, figures and graphs
-
Presentation of numbers and statistics
-
International System of Units
​
LANGUAGE EDITING
This involves aligning the language of your manuscript with conventional and idiomatic English. This includes checking the following elements:
​
​
-
Grammar
-
Word choice, including technical nomenclature
-
Style, including making texts more clear, concise, correct, consistent, coherent, and compelling
-
Tone, involves ensuring that the word choice is appropriate for your audience and type of manuscript you are writing
-
Rhetorical conventions and organizational structures of scientific manuscripts
-
Textual and formatting conventions, including font size and type, margins, and spacing, and other typography issues
​
CONTENT EDITING
In a medium copyedit, I do a limited amount of content editing and fact-checking unless the author requests more in-depth fact-checking. At a minimum, if I see irregularities or questionable facts and content, I will query the author about these items. I can also do a more systematic editing of content and fact-checking as well as annotation of text, as found in editing of manuscripts in a medical legal regulatory review, if an author requests this. This may include the following:
​
-
Fact-checking by consulting primary reference sources or by referencing the related literature
-
Verifying that your summary of findings of other studies is consistent with the article you are summarizing
-
Checking numbers that do not add up or missing data
-
Pointing out issues in reporting statistical data
-
Check for verbatim text from the reference source
​
CORRELATING PARTS
Correlating parts involves verifying that sections of a manuscript logically and consistently connect. Some items I check include:​
​​
-
Verifying that your summary of findings of other studies is consistent with the source article you are citing
-
Verifying that numerical data presented in the text is consistent throughout the manuscript, including the tables, figures, abstract, introduction, methods, results, and discussion
-
Checking for consistency between in-text references to tables and figures and correctly labeling these items
-
Check for consistency in typeface formatting of levels of titles, headings, and subheadings
-
Checking description in captions and labeling against content presented in tables and figures
-
Verifying that all items presented in tables are presented consistently and use the same terminology or units of measure throughout the table
-
Verifying consistency of in-text citations and footnotes against references
-
Cross-checking table of contents with sections of the manuscript
-
Verifying that all text and numerical data are consistently formatted throughout all tables and figures
​
EDITING REFERENCES
-
Align references with a particular style such as, AMA-11, Chicago, APA, CSE: Scientific Style and Format
-
Check order and formatting style of authors, titles, publication dates, publisher, etc.
-
Verify that links are active and correct; add a doi when applicable
-
Verify that references are current, relevant, and high quality
​
ALIGNING WITH A JOURNAL'S GUIDELINES FOR AUTHORS
-
Align your article with a journal's formatting and style preferences
-
Confirm that references are consistent with journal's guidelines
-
Confirm that word count for abstract and other sections of an article are within a journal's word limit
-
Verify that tables and figures are aligned with journal guidelines and specifications